Book Review: My Brother’s Keeper by Ben Schenkman

Reviewed: June 27th, 2026
Released: March 20th, 2026
Genre: Urban Fantasy

Magic is real, demons walk the earth, and Max’s brother is dead.

Max Asher, Jewish mystic and private-eye, never thought he’d be coming back to his home town to bury his twin brother, Solomon. He definitely never thought the funeral would turn into a case, but when Sol’s widow Gabby asks him to investigate the cause of death, “Uncle Max” is on the job.

When Max kicks the demon’s nest, he uncovers a conspiracy that forces him to reevaluate everything he thought he knew about his brother. Unfamiliar local politics blur the line between the supernatural and the mundane, and soon, fighting for justice becomes dangerously literal. If Max can uncover the murderer, he might just save his brother’s soul—but if he can’t, he’ll fall victim to the same deadly fate.

Putting the past to rest is going to take more than a shovel full of dirt.

Helen’s Thoughts: 4/5

An interesting fantasy tale set in a world with magic about a man who fell out with his twin brother years ago, only to find out that he died before they could reconcile. Returning for the funeral, Max realises that his brother’s death may not have been as innocent as he first thought.

Set in a very well realised world, with enough history to give it depth, Max’s investigations take him into the world of underground magic. The emotional damage of looking exactly like his twin, both for Max and those who knew his brother well, is well written, with the shock and sorrow very well portrayed.

Very clever twist, that I did not see coming and won’t spoil, but in hindsight explains much. There is strong dependency on the Jewish faith and tradition, which although it is often referenced adds colour to the story and you don’t need to know what it all means, though it would probably help. It doesn’t affect the general plot of a PI searching for the truth, but enhances the characters reactions and decisions.

Easy to read if you can glide over the Jewish references you don’t understand. If you can’t do that, then you may struggle to read this book.


Purchase My Brother’s Keeper

Link to book on Amazon UK: eBook | Paperback

Link to book on Amazon US: eBook | Paperback

As an Amazon Associate I may benefit from purchases made using these links.

If you enjoy fantasy books then you will love my epic fantasy Sentinal series or the Romantic Fantasy SoulMist series and now Harmony, a dystopian science fantasy.

Start the adventure and stay for the journey. Sign up to my newsletter and download a free novella called Sentinals Stirring and get notified when my next books are published.

By clicking the sign up button above, you agree to share your email address with the site owner and the newsletter platform provider to receive marketing, updates, and other emails from the site owner. Use the unsubscribe link in those emails to opt out at any time.

By signing up to my newsletter, you agree to receive commercial information from Helen Garraway, located at 61 Bridge St, Kingston, Hertfordshire, UK (Data Administrator). You can withdraw your consent at any time. The data will be processed until the consent is withdrawn.

Alliance of Independent Authors